Derek Chauvin Pleads For Mercy

Photo by Ricardo IV Tamayo on Unsplash

A friend of mine texted me that Derek Chauvin had asked his judge to shorten his prison term.

I wasn’t expecting the former officer would do so but here’s my take on it.

Mercy has to be earned.

Mr Chauvin was reckless as he abused George Floyd in plain sight, with others filming him, even warning him that the man might not survive the oppressive knee. And yet Mr Chauvin thought he was doing his job.

Never mind that George Floyd was not a threat, for he was lying prone on the ground, handcuffed behind his back, begging for relief.

Mr Chauvin still kept the knee on.

That he persisted, undeterred by the cries for him to cease, sparked turmoil in the nation and took the former officer to court where he was found guilty of 2nd degree unintentional murder, 3rd degree murder and 2nddegree manslaughter.

Mr Chauvin has a right to ask for mercy, but mercy has to be earned.

His request can be seen as a first step in the long journey ahead in search of his humanity. The humanity he had been running away from all of his life and the absence of which was most glaring the day he took George Floyd’s life.

How he became the man he became only Mr Chauvin knows.

We hope he will tell us one day.

Throughout his career, he appears to have done little to try and overcome his flaws. And if they were noticed by his superiors, little of consequence was done to urge him to check them.

And so, in a way, the tragedy of May 25th 2020, was inevitable.

It could have happened any other day or to any other person, but that was the day he arrested George Floyd.

Seeing Mr Chauvin in his suit, seated next to his lawyers in the court room, evoked a certain sadness. There he was, without his uniform to protect him, without his badge to insulate him from life.

It is very sad to see a grown man not challenge himself to learn the plight of those whom he dealt with in the course of his work.

Only now, after repeatedly viewing the clip of his killing George Floyd, has Mr Chauvin begun to realize what he did. Only now, then, is he starting on his journey to become a human being.

Mercy has to be earned and Mr Chauvin should begin immediately on his task.

If you are reading this, here are some suggestions to you:

Start a journal where you write down all your feelings and thoughts. It is an exercise in listening to yourself. As you learn to do so, you also learn to listen to others.

Read stories about people’s sufferings. All people’s sufferings, no matter what their race, to learn how they came to understand their pain and overcome it.

As you do you will begin to put together your own story. The story of how you grew so insensitive to the suffering of others and how you came to devalue them.

Just like you were blind and deaf to the suffering of others, there are other police officers out there who are just as blind and deaf as you were.

Reach out to them. Try to educate them. Encourage them to connect with their higher selves.

As you do, you will be helping them exercise better judgment in the field and in their lives. And they will be grateful.

Write to them and let them write to you.

Your journey to find your sense of compassion will then assist other officers in finding theirs.

And you will be saving lives.

Save the letters of appreciation you receive and one day you may wish to share them with the family of George Floyd. And perhaps one day they will choose to advocate for your release.

Whether they do or not, you must start to rebuild your life by repairing your mistakes.

And you must do it for you. For your sanity. For your wisdom.

You are a young man. Build yourself up as a compassionate human being.

Work hard, Mr Chauvin, and never give up.

If not too damaged and if circumstances are not overwhelming, we can choose our fates.

Dare to do so.

And maybe your efforts to earn mercy will become an inspiration for the rest of us.

Dare to transform yourself.

Good luck and best wishes.

Oscar Valdes.

Also available in Apple and Google podcasts,, Spotify, and others.

Letters to A Shooter is available in video at




writer and psychiatrist with an interest in current affairs

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

Re-framing Masculinity Outside The Household

To my friends that like the simple world of Jordan B Peterson

Don’t Dish It If You Can’t Take It

Where and when you enter

The Dawn of Identity Crisis in the 21st Century

Coffee Break: Starbucks and Racial Bias

The God Of Virginity Is a Woman’s Demon: Everything You Should Know About FGM

Why Everyone Should Care about Indigenous People, Every Day

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store


writer and psychiatrist with an interest in current affairs

More from Medium

Digital Authoritarianism on the Rise: Insights from Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine

Is Russia a Paper Tiger?

Russia-Ukraine Crisis — litmus test for the “rules-based” global order

In Search Of Enemies